David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

Posted by Pink Zeppelin on Sun, 12/19/04 - 01:49:06.

[The body of this post has been reconstituted from replies so it may differ from what was originally written.]

Related News:
Jimmy Page Nominated for Knighthood



Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

he who dies and has the most toys, wins.
Gilmour has 'The Strat' the number 1, adonised scratchplate, and he has more hair too, but of course page is the better guitar player, but who cares about that, dave has all the gear.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

Lets put them in a ring and find out.;)

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

: .

is it harder to play guitar or to know how to use all those effects?

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

: is it harder to play guitar or to know how to use all those effects?

Graham Coxon

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

ok first of all, the key to playing like david gilmour is NOT in the effects whatsoever. He is an absolute master of bending and vibrato, he has a ridiculous amount of control over his instrument. It is damn near impossible to sound like Gilmour, even if you have all the exact same gear as him. Listen to solos like the ones in "Mother" or the "Echoes" live version from Pompeii. The subtleties in his playing that makes it flow so beautifully are mind blowing. His tone simply complements it. Not to disrespect Jimmy Paige, he is an amazing playing who reshaped the face of Rock and ROll. However, i think it is ultimatly harder to play like Dave Gilmour than it is Paige. Gilmour is a god.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

ummm, Echoes is one of the Best Gilmour songs, and Achilles last stand is one of Pages, put em head to head

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

Id have to say that overall Gilmour is more creative, but page is one of the best guitar players

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

You guys dont know what your talking about

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

who cares , listen to em both

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

thats cause your all wrong

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

no you dont know Miss

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

none of you guys know,jeff beck is the best

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

hahahhahahha, u serious?

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

id have to go with Slash

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

What are you guys smoking? Naturally Page is good, but he's seriously sloppy and puts out way to much shit. Too much shit sounds the same.

Now Master Gilmour, that guy's got flavor. Every album rules. Hands down Gilmour is king. Arguing simply shows you've got no idea what you're talking about.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

yea id have to agree that Gilmour is the man everything is so unique with his music plus unlike page, he sings

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

No way! JIMMY PAGE HANDS DOWN!. i dont even like pink floyd

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

CELEBRITY DEATH MATCH! Both are great guitar players but I want to see them fight.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

David Gilmour is the best guitar player i've listen to. He's the most creative and no one can play a guitar with the feeling that he puts in his fender. You have to listen Echoes, all the Crazy Diamond Piece and also Comfortably Numb.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

David Gilmour is the best guitar player i've listen to. He's the most creative and no one can play a guitar with the feeling that he puts in his fender. You have to listen Echoes, all the Crazy Diamond Piece and also Comfortably Numb.

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

They Play differently, you can't compare them, Page is heavy and fast and Gilmour is Slow and emotional

Re: David Gilmour Vs. Jimmy Page,... Who wins

Page every time!! He can play all styles, heavy and fast slow emotional. And some great finger picking.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Do not include any spaces in your answer.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

Contact | Contents | Privacy Policy | Forum

This site is published by Hitsquad Pty Ltd. Copyright © 1999 - 2021 , All Rights Reserved.

Affiliate Notice: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.